How to interview candidates: questions, scoring and a practical scorecard

6 mins
Sellick  Partnership

By Sellick Partnership

A well-planned interview process helps employers make hiring decisions while creating a positive experience for candidates. From asking the right questions to assessing answers consistently, a structured approach can help you identify the skills and experience needed for a role. 

At Sellick Partnership, we help employers across the public, private and not-for-profit sectors with their recruitment needs. In this guide we share practical advice on how to structure interviews, develop relevant questions and assess candidates fairly and consistently. 

Here are our top tips on how to develop a robust interview process for your business.

Why a detailed interview process matters

Hiring mistakes are expensive; the cost of recruiting, onboarding, and replacing the wrong person can quickly add up, especially when factoring in lost productivity and team disruption. A clear and consistent process can help reduce bias, improve the candidate experience and support better hiring decisions.

Where possible, keep your process streamlined - the fewer stages required to make a confident decision, the better the candidate experience and the lower the risk of process fatigue or unnecessary barriers. For more advice on streamlining your wider recruitment process, read our guide on how to improve your recruitment process and reduce time-to-hire.

Step 1: Agree your interview assessment criteria 

Before you start searching for the right candidate, take time to evaluate the role you're hiring for: 

  • What skills, knowledge and experience are essential for success in this role? 
  • What behaviours and competencies are important for the position?
  • What would success look like in this role, and what skills or behaviours would help someone achieve it?

Make a list of these requirements and ensure everyone involved in the selection process agrees on the criteria for evaluating candidates. These should form the basis of your interview questions and scoring system, helping you assess applicants fairly and consistently.

Avoid looking for 'social fit' (e.g. similar backgrounds, universities, interests). Instead, prioritise relevant skills, behaviours, values, and potential. This can help widen your talent pool and reduce the influence of affinity bias. 

Think about the composition of your interview panel too. Aim for diversity in background, discipline and perspective and avoid 'group think' by encouraging interviewers to score candidates independently before discussing their assessments. 

For further guidance, explore our Recruitment Inclusion Checklist or read our guide to writing effective job descriptions.

Step 2: Structure your interviews for consistency 

Having a set format ensures all candidates are evaluated fairly. A recommended structure might look like: 

  • Introduction: Small talk, explain the format, help candidates feel comfortable.
  • CV and fact-based questions: Clarify details from their CV and career history. 
  • Technical and competency questions: Assess experience and expertise through real-world examples. 
  • Situational questions: Present candidates with a realistic workplace scenario to understand how they would approach a problem or make a decision.
  • Candidate questions and wrap up: Allow candidates time to ask questions and outline next steps. 

Standardise the interview by using the same core questions in the same order for each candidate. Provide interviewers with scoring criteria and a scorecard so decisions are based on evidence, not instinct. 

Step 3: Prepare your interview questions

Once you have shortlisted candidates based on their CVs, the next step is to develop a strong set of interview questions that allow candidates to demonstrate their skills and experience. 

There are several types of questions to consider:

  • Fact-based or general questions: These help clarify information from a candidate’s CV, career history and motivations. For example: What interests you about this role and our organisation? 
  • Situational or hypothetical questions: These explore how candidates would approach a particular workplace scenario, helping you assess their judgement and problem-solving skills. For example: How would you handle competing deadlines when several stakeholders need your support? 
  • Competency-based and behavioural questions: These ask candidates to provide real-life examples of how they have handled specific situations, what actions they personally took and why. The goal is to assess their competencies through past actions. For example: Tell me about a time you improved a process/task.
  • Technical questions: These assess the specialist knowledge and practical skills needed for the role. For example: How would you approach [task] using [tool/software]?

For competency-based questions, the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) can help candidates structure their examples and interviewers assess the evidence provided. Encourage candidates to explain the situation, their responsibilities, the actions they personally took and the outcome.

It is important to take care when preparing interview questions. Avoid discriminatory or unnecessarily personal questions that are unrelated to the candidate's ability to perform the role.

Questions should focus on relevant skills, experience, values and workplace behaviours rather than personal backgrounds or perceived 'culture fit'.

Be mindful that some questions or assessment formats may need to be adjusted to accommodate individual needs, including those of disabled or neurodivergent candidates. 

If using psychometric testing, consider whether it is genuinely necessary for the role. Ensure the purpose is clear, the assessment is appropriate and validated for its intended use, and reasonable adjustments are available where required.

Example questions to ask during an interview 

The following questions can be adapted to assess candidates across different professional-services roles:

  • Problem-solving: Can you give an example of a complex problem you resolved? What steps did you take?
  • Experience and achievements: What have been your most significant professional achievements, and what was your personal contribution?
  • Communication: Tell us about a time you had to explain complex information to somebody unfamiliar with the subject. How did you approach it?
  • Prioritisation: How would you manage multiple urgent deadlines with limited resources?
  • Decision-making: Describe a situation where you had to make a decision without having all the information you needed. How did you proceed?
  • Collaboration: Give an example of when you worked with colleagues or stakeholders to achieve a shared objective. What was your role?
  • Initiative: Tell us about a time you identified an opportunity to improve a process or way of working. What did you do?
  • Adaptability: Describe a situation where priorities changed unexpectedly. How did you respond?

Where appropriate, use follow-up questions such as "What was your specific responsibility?", "How did you decide what to do?" or "What was the outcome?" to establish the candidate's individual contribution.

Tip: Consider creating a standard interview pack for hiring managers across temporary, contract and permanent roles. This could include agreed questions, assessment criteria, scoring guidance, information about reducing bias and prompts for reasonable adjustments. 

Step 4: Use a structured rating system

It might be tempting to use initial impressions to compare candidates against each other, but this can be problematic. The goal of the interview is to find the candidate who is best qualified for the job, not necessarily the person you 'click' with. Conversations should focus on assessing relevant skills and abilities, rather than personal connections.

A structured rating system can help you make fairer, more consistent hiring decisions by assessing each candidate against the same criteria. 

Before interviewing, agree which competencies matter most for the role, how they will be assessed and what a strong answer should demonstrate. Interviewers can then use a scorecard to record evidence and assign a rating for each criterion.

Example interview scorecard

The following example can be adapted to suit different roles and specialisms:

Assessment criteriaExample interview questionEvidence to look forScore (1–5)Candidate evidence/notes
Technical skillsCan you describe a project or task where you used relevant specialist skills?Appropriate knowledge, practical application and results.To be completed by interviewerTo be completed by interviewer
CommunicationTell us about a time you explained complex information to someone unfamiliar with the subject.Clear explanations, awareness of the audience and effective communication.To be completed by interviewerTo be completed by interviewer
Problem-solvingDescribe a challenging problem you resolved at work.Logical approach, sound judgement, individual contribution and outcome.To be completed by interviewerTo be completed by interviewer
PrioritisationHow would you manage several competing deadlines?Ability to assess urgency, organise work and communicate priorities.To be completed by interviewerTo be completed by interviewer
InitiativeTell us about a time you identified an improvement and took action.Proactive behaviour, ownership and measurable or observable results.To be completed by interviewerTo be completed by interviewer


How to score candidates consistently

Use a simple 1–5 scale, with agreed descriptions for each score:

  • 1 – Poor: Does not demonstrate the required competency, or provides little relevant evidence.
  • 2 – Limited: Shows some understanding but provides insufficient evidence of practical application.
  • 3 – Meets expectations: Demonstrates the required competency with a relevant example and satisfactory outcome.
  • 4 – Strong: Provides clear, detailed evidence of the competency and a positive outcome.
  • 5 – Excellent: Demonstrates comprehensive evidence of the required competency, sound judgement and a clear, relevant outcome.

The descriptions should be adapted to reflect the level of experience and requirements of the position.

Worked example: Scoring a problem-solving answer

Imagine you're interviewing candidates for a role where problem-solving is an essential skill.

You ask: "Tell us about a time you encountered a challenging problem at work. How did you approach it, and what was the outcome?"

  • Weak answer (1–2): The candidate gives a vague example, struggles to explain their own contribution or cannot describe how the problem was resolved.
  • Adequate answer (3): The candidate explains a relevant problem, outlines the steps they took and describes a satisfactory outcome.
  • Strong answer (4–5): The candidate provides a specific example, explains their reasoning and individual actions, considers alternative approaches and demonstrates what they achieved or learned from the experience.

This approach makes it easier to distinguish between candidates based on the evidence they provide rather than personal impressions.

Making your final assessment

Ask each interviewer to record relevant evidence and score candidates independently before discussing their views with the wider panel. Where different scores are awarded, return to the examples provided by the candidate rather than relying on instinct.

Before making a final decision, check that:

  • All candidates have been assessed against the same essential criteria.
  • Scores are supported by specific examples or evidence.
  • Any differences in interviewers' assessments have been discussed.
  • Decisions are based on the requirements of the role, with reasonable adjustments taken into account.
  • The reasons for the decision have been recorded clearly.

If certain competencies are more important than others, you can agree a weighting for each criterion in advance. Apply this consistently to every candidate and ensure that essential requirements are not overlooked simply because someone achieves a high overall score.

Keep interview notes and assessment records secure, in line with your organisation’s data protection policies and retention requirements.

Step 5: Improve your candidate experience

An effective interview process benefits candidates as much as employers. Providing a positive experience can also help candidates feel confident about joining your organisation.

Here's how to improve the candidate journey:

  • Communicate clearly: Let candidates know what to expect before the interview, including the format, who they'll be meeting, any assessments involved and how long the process is likely to take.
  • Prepare thoroughly: Read CVs ahead of time and avoid repetitive questions. 
  • Be welcoming: Use body language to show you're engaged and attentive, and help candidates feel comfortable. 
  • Listen actively: Don't dominate the conversation. Give candidates enough time to explain their answers and ask questions of their own. 
  • Be open about the role: Give candidates an honest picture of the day-to-day responsibilities, working environment and any challenges they might face. This helps them decide whether the opportunity is right for them.
  • Take notes: Keep accurate, relevant records to support fair and consistent decisions after multiple interviews. 
  • Give feedback: Where possible, provide timely, constructive feedback, including to unsuccessful applicants. Be clear about when candidates can expect to hear from you.

Make reasonable adjustments easy to request. Let candidates know in advance that adjustments are available and ask whether there is anything they need to participate fully in the interview. This might include accessible formats, additional time, questions provided in advance or adjustments to interview technology or the environment. Taking these steps helps create a more inclusive and transparent process, allowing candidates to demonstrate their abilities and make an informed decision about the opportunity.

Our final tips for success

Creating a fair, consistent and inclusive interview process is an important part of making better hiring decisions. By agreeing your assessment criteria, asking relevant questions, and using a structured scoring system, you can identify candidates with the skills and potential to succeed in the role. 

Remember, interviews should be a two-way conversation. Alongside evaluating candidates, give them the opportunity to learn about your organisation, understand the role and decide whether it's right for them. Taking a considered approach will help you make more confident hiring decisions while creating a positive experience for everyone involved.

How Sellick Partnership can help

At Sellick Partnership, we support organisations across the UK with their recruitment needs. Our experienced recruitment consultants can help you identify and shortlist suitable candidates, advise on interview structures and support you throughout the recruitment process.

Whether you're recruiting for a temporary, contract or permanent position, submit a vacancy or contact our team to discuss how we can help.

You can also explore our employer resources for further recruitment advice.