How to negotiate salary after a job offer: practical tips and example

5 mins
Sellick  Partnership

By Sellick Partnership

Receiving a job offer is an important step in your job search. But what if the salary is lower than you expected?

You do not have to accept the first figure immediately. Equally, you do not need to negotiate simply because you have received an offer. The key is to decide whether a conversation is worthwhile, understand what you are asking for and explain your reasons clearly.

A professional, well-informed discussion can help you and the employer reach a decision that works for both sides. However, not every employer will have room to increase its offer.

This guide explains when to negotiate salary after a job offer, how much to ask for, what to say and what to do if the answer is no.

Jump to salary negotiation checklist ↓

Should you negotiate salary after a job offer?

Not always. If the offer meets your expectations, reflects the responsibilities of the job and compares well with similar roles, you may be happy to accept it.

It is worth discussing the offer if you have a clear reason to request a change, rather than assuming every salary is open to negotiation.

For example, you may want to discuss a possible raise in the salary if:

  • The offer is lower than the salary range discussed during the recruitment process
  • Your research suggests that comparable roles typically pay more
  • You've discovered that the position involves greater responsibilities than initially advertised
  • You have specialist skills or experience that are particularly valuable to the employer
  • The overall package falls short of what you need to make the move worthwhile

Before making a request, consider what you discussed about salary earlier in the process. If the offer matches an agreed figure, explain clearly what new information has changed your expectations.

Your aim should be to reach an informed agreement, not to negotiate for the sake of it.

How to prepare before negotiating a salary offer

Review the full written offer before responding, including the starting salary, benefits, working arrangements and any conditions that could affect your decision.

Then establish a realistic salary target and the minimum overall package you would be comfortable accepting.

1. Check the market rate for the role

Compare salaries for genuinely similar roles, taking account of location, sector, seniority, working pattern and responsibilities.

Useful sources include:

  • Current job adverts for similar roles
  • Industry salary surveys and benchmarking reports
  • Salaries advertised by similar organisations
  • Market insights from specialist recruitment consultants

Look beyond job titles. For example, a Finance Manager in a small organisation may have a different remit from someone with the same title in a large national organisation.

Where a role sits within a formal pay grade or published salary band, as is often the case in the public sector, check whether the employer has scope to appoint above the starting point.

A specialist Recruitment Consultant can add context from current vacancies and recent recruitment activity, although advertised salaries and surveys will not always show the full picture.

2. Identify the experience that supports your request

Be ready to explain why a different salary would reflect the value you could bring to this particular role.

Focus on the most relevant evidence, such as:

  • Specialist qualifications or technical knowledge
  • Experience managing teams, budgets or complex projects
  • Skills that are difficult to recruit for
  • A proven track record of improving processes, reducing costs or delivering results
  • Additional responsibilities discussed during the interview process

For example, if the role involves implementing a finance system and you have already led a comparable project, explain the scope of that work and the outcome.

Choose one or two persuasive examples rather than repeating your full CV.

3. Review the full package

Compare the overall offer with your priorities, not just your current salary.

Check pension contributions, annual leave, working patterns, bonus eligibility, professional subscriptions, training support and any relevant contractual terms. Not every element will be negotiable.

For example, a role with a slightly lower salary could still suit you if it offers meaningful flexibility or progression. Equally, an attractive benefit may have little practical value to you.

Decide which parts of the offer matter most before you raise a request.

How much more salary should you ask for?

There is no reliable percentage that works for every offer. Base your request on comparable salaries, the responsibilities of the role, your experience and any pay band the employer has shared.

Choose a specific target and decide privately what you would accept. This will help you respond if the employer proposes a different figure.

For example, if the offer is £42,000 and comparable roles suggest £45,000 is realistic for your experience, you could ask whether the employer can move to £45,000.

A specific figure is usually clearer than a general request for more money. If you give a range, be comfortable with the lower figure.

You could say:

"Having considered the responsibilities of the role and comparable salaries, I was hoping for a starting salary of £45,000. Is there flexibility to discuss that figure?"

Explain your reasoning briefly and listen to the response. You do not need to inflate the figure simply to leave room to negotiate.

If the difference between the offer and your target is substantial, ask your Consultant or the employer whether the budget could realistically accommodate it before pursuing a detailed negotiation.

How to negotiate salary after receiving a job offer: step by step

Once you have reviewed the offer and set your target, raise the question before formally accepting the terms.

If a Recruitment Consultant introduced you to the employer, speak to them first. They can explain what has already been discussed about pay and, where appropriate, raise your request with the employer.

1. Thank them for the offer

Start positively and confirm your interest in the role. You can be enthusiastic about an opportunity while still asking a reasonable question about salary.

2. Make a clear, evidence-based request

State the figure you are seeking and give a short reason linked to the role, your experience or relevant market comparisons. Avoid presenting a long list of demands.

3. Agree the next step

The hiring manager may need approval from HR or another decision-maker. Ask when you can expect an update and respond within the timeframe you have agreed.

Example: what to say when negotiating salary by phone

If you receive a verbal offer, thank the employer and ask for the full details in writing if you have not already received them. You can request time to review the offer before responding.

If you are ready to raise salary, you could say:

"Thank you for the offer. I am really pleased to hear it. Having learned more about the role and its responsibilities, I was hoping for a starting salary closer to £[amount], based on my experience in [relevant area]. Is there any flexibility to discuss this?"

Keep the conversation constructive and allow the employer time to respond.

If you are not ready to negotiate straight away, ask when they would like your decision and agree when you will get back to them.

Example: salary negotiation email after a job offer

An email can work well if the employer has sent a written offer or you would prefer to set out your request clearly.

Adapt this example to the role and your circumstances:

Subject: [Job title] offer - salary discussion

Hi [name],

Thank you for offering me the [job title] position. I enjoyed meeting the team and am pleased to have received the offer.

Having reviewed the details, I would like to ask whether there is flexibility on the starting salary. Based on the role's responsibilities, my experience in [relevant area] and comparable positions, I was hoping for £[amount].

I remain very interested in the opportunity and would welcome a conversation if that would be helpful.

Thank you for considering my request. I look forward to hearing from you.

Kind regards, [Your name]

Keep the message short and specific. If you are working through a Recruitment Consultant, agree with them who will communicate the request so the employer does not receive conflicting messages.

What should you avoid when negotiating salary?

Keep your explanation focused on the job and the value you can offer, while being honest about the package you need to make a move worthwhile.

Personal circumstances may affect your decision, but they are usually less persuasive as the main reason for increasing an employer's salary budget.

Try not to base your request solely on:

  • Increased mortgage or household bills
  • Personal financial commitments
  • Wanting a particular percentage increase on your current salary without considering the new role
  • What a friend or former colleague earns in a different position
  • The belief that every employer has money available for negotiation

Avoid ultimatums you are not prepared to follow through on. If you have a genuine minimum requirement, you can explain it calmly without suggesting that the employer has acted unfairly.

What else can you negotiate if the salary cannot increase?

An employer may be keen to hire you but unable to change the salary because of its budget, pay structure or internal policies. This can be especially relevant to roles with fixed grades or salary bands.

If the salary is fixed, ask whether another part of the package could better meet your priorities. Possible areas to explore, where the employer's policies allow, include:

  • Annual leave: Is there any scope for additional leave, or a scheme to buy extra days?
  • Flexible working: Can we discuss the working pattern or office attendance requirements?
  • Professional subscriptions: Could the organisation cover fees linked to the role?
  • Training and development: Is there funding or study leave for relevant qualifications?
  • Pension: What employer contribution applies, and are enhanced or matched contributions available under the scheme?
  • Salary review: Could we agree when my salary will next be reviewed and what criteria will apply?

A scheduled review is not a promise of a pay rise. Confirm any agreed arrangements in writing and check whether they are discretionary, subject to performance or governed by a published policy.

What if the employer cannot improve the offer?

If the employer confirms that its offer is final, decide whether the full package meets your needs and career priorities.

Think about the responsibilities, progression opportunities, working arrangements, commute and other aspects that first attracted you to the role.

Compare those advantages with any gap between the offer and the minimum package you are prepared to accept.

You can still accept the original offer after asking a reasonable question about salary. A refusal to increase pay does not automatically mean the role is wrong for you.

Equally, if the overall package does not work for you, it is reasonable to decline politely rather than accept terms you expect to regret.

When should you stop negotiating?

Once you have made a clear request, considered any alternative and received the employer's final response, focus on making your decision.

Avoid reopening agreed terms or adding new requests without a material reason. If you receive a counterproposal, assess it against the priorities you set before negotiating.

If you accept, check that the final salary and any agreed benefits or working arrangements appear in the written offer or contract before you rely on them.

For advice on accepting an offer, managing a counteroffer from your current employer and next steps, see our guide to accepting a job offer.

How can a Recruitment Consultant help with salary negotiations?

A specialist Recruitment Consultant can help you judge whether a proposed salary is realistic and how to approach a discussion with the employer.

At Sellick Partnership, our Consultants support candidates with salary expectations before interviews and can help with offer discussions where we are involved in the recruitment process.

Depending on the vacancy and the employer's process, this may include:

  • Providing insight into current market salaries for your profession and location
  • Helping you establish realistic salary expectations before interviews begin
  • Explaining any known salary band or restrictions, while checking what flexibility the employer has confirmed
  • Advising whether negotiating an offer is appropriate
  • Communicating your expectations and negotiating with the employer on your behalf
  • Helping you understand the full employment package before making a decision

If you are working with a Consultant, share your priorities early and keep them informed about any change to your salary expectations.

Salary negotiation checklist

Before you respond to an offer, check that you can answer these questions:

  • Have I reviewed the full written offer and the terms that matter to me?
  • Have I checked salaries for comparable roles and any published pay band?
  • Do I understand the role's actual responsibilities and level of seniority?
  • Can I explain briefly why my proposed salary is reasonable?
  • Do I know my target figure and the minimum package I would accept?
  • Have I identified which benefits or working arrangements matter most?
  • Can I make my request clearly and professionally?
  • Have I decided how I will respond if the employer says no?
  • If I am using a Recruitment Consultant, have I discussed the offer with them first?

Get support with your next job offer

Salary negotiations do not have to be complicated. The most useful starting point is a clear understanding of the role, the market and what matters to you.

Sellick Partnership's specialist Recruitment Consultants can help candidates understand salary expectations and review job offers where we are supporting their search.

Explore our latest vacancies or contact our team to discuss your next career move.